Inquire Now

Let's bake!

We are not a storefront bakery, all items are made to order.

Sunday-9am-noon
Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday - CLOSED 
Thursday-noon-6pm
Friday-10am-5pm
Saturday-8am-2pm

3527 Washington Ave
Finleyville, PA 15332

412-855-4918

icingonthecakepgh@gmail.com

Start the order process. (For weddings, click here!)

Pittsburgh -South Hills -South Park -Bethel Park -Peters -Baldwin -Washington -Mt.Lebanon -Pleasant Hills -Bridgeville-MORE!

we deliver to... 

Time to start planning your custom cake!
Read over our menus and FAQ page to be able to answer the questions to the best of your ability.
*Fill out the cake order form below and we will respond within the next 3-4 business days.
*Please note that all orders must be placed within a 2-3 week window of the date needed.
*We reserve the right to decline orders that are outside of this window

How much are your cakes?

That is a very hard question, they vary based on size and how detailed a cake can be.

Are you able to make anything without a certain allergen?

No. We are NOT an allergen free bakery. We bake with many different products that could contain but aren't limited to. Peanuts, Tree Nuts, Gluten, Eggs, Milk, Soy.

Can I stop in to buy baked goods?

We are not a storefront bakery for everyday items. The only exception is pop ups that we may offer. As well as the day before or on certain holidays. We always will share on our social media pages and update the website when in store stopping is available.


How far in advance should I place my order?

The earlier the better, about 2-3 weeks is normal but not always guaranteed we have availability honestly a month out you have a better chance of securing an order.


Can I pay for my cake in full when I pick it up?

NO! All orders require a 50% deposit. That deposit is non-refundable after 4 days prior to your pickup date. If you need to move your event for a certain reason, please check with us to make sure we can accommodate your new event date and we will move your deposit.


What if I need a cake within a week?

You can check out our ready to go tab and that will show you all the options of cakes we have available as well as other treats with a quick turnaround time for those last minute events.


Can I get each tier a different batter flavor?

Yes! There is not additional cost to have each tier be a different flavor. The cost can change based on the filling you choose in each tier though.


© icing on the cake, 2025  |  legal  |  site DESIGN: SARAH KLEIST customizations by SIGHT CREATIVE CO