icing on the cake bakery

Congratulations you're getting married, time to create the cake of your dreams!

learn more

So... how does it work?

you order

we discuss

i bake

you wedding!

Fill out the order form below with your information and wedding details, & we'll get the ball rolling!

Bringing your vision to life is our greatest priority. Depending on your order, we'll chat via email or phone about your dream treat.

Once the details are ironed out, I go shopping, come up with a gameplan, and start baking whatever we discussed!

You can either pick up your order before your event or we can deliver; then, it's time to party, relax, & enjoy!

"Morgan it was beyond amazing!!! You are so good at what you do!!"

"I think I have gotten like 10 texts the last couple of days. They not only loved the look of the cake, but loved how delicious it was."

"You are amazing the cake was absolutely perfect!! šŸ„°"

"Just had to message you and tell you the cake was incredible. Everyone was asking where we got it!!"

"Just saw a photo of the cake again and once again you nailed it!! ā¤ļøā¤ļø"

"Thank you so much! Truly love your work. It's so beautiful and delicious."

Do you offer wedding cake tastings?

Yes! Our in person tastings are $60 which include an hour to discuss your dream cake as well as to taste your different cake choices. We also offer to-go tasting boxes that are $25 and we have a phone conversation to then further discuss your options. When you inquire, be sure to select either an in-person or to-go tasting.

How many people can come to the tasting?

At this time we only recommend you and your partner come since it's your wedding day and your cake but if a parent or planner would like to join they can but they will not have their own cake flavors to try.

If flowers are needed on my cake will you place them on?

We can absolutely place your real or fake flowers on the cake, as well as your cake topper if needed. All flowers must be provided by you or a florist.


How far in advance should I place my order?

We start to accept orders for your wedding date up to a year out but typically the 8-6 month range is ideal.


Do you make fake cakes?

Of course, we love them! They are a great option for many reasons. Caterers will not have to move or cut a large tall cake. If you don't need/ want to feed a ton of people but still want that grand and elaborate cake. You still will be able to have your cake cutting photo since only a small section of the cake will be real to cut into. You then can leave the cake out all night for your guests to look at. You can then feed your guests with cupcakes (our #1 option) or sheet cakes.


Is it possible to save the top tier of my cake?

Actually here at Icing on the Cake, there is no need for that! We provide a completely free anniversary cake that will be delivered on the day of your wedding that is boxed, wrapped, and labeled all ready for your freezer.


Will you deliver?

Yes! We require all tiered cakes to be delivered. It's your wedding day. We want to make sure your cake arrives safely to your venue. If just have a single tiered cake you do have the option of pickup by you the day before or a family member.


Do you offer cookies to purchase for our Pittsburgh cookie table?

Yes! Click here to view our cookie menu


Wedding Cookies

Who doesn't love a good ole' classic cookie? We offer a variety of both traditional and original flavorsā€”plus bagging options, in case a party favor is more your style.

Sizes & Servings

cookies

$21.00 / Dozen

  • Chocolate Chunk
  • Oatmeal Raisin
  • White Chocolate Cranberry
  • Snickerdoodles
  • Peanut Butter kiss
  • M&M
  • Sprinkle Thumbprint

inquire

view gallery

delivery available for $2.00/mile

  • Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip
  • Raspberry Nut Thumbprint
  • Lemon Crinkle
  • Oreo Balls
  • Buckeves
  • Mini Brownies

whaddya say?

Ready to put in your order? We're so excited to           for you!

At Icing on the Cake, we believe the details matterā€”and custom treats can take any event from fun to fabulous. We'd love to create something special for you & your guests.

Ready to make this official? Fill out our order form with as much detail as possible to request your custom treats. We'll be in touch within 48 business hours about next steps!

inquire now

bake

View the full gallery >

Ā© icing on the cake, 2025  |  legal  |  site DESIGN: SARAH KLEIST customizations by SIGHT CREATIVE CO