Custom Cakes
We bake custom cakes for weddings, birthdays, and every other event you can imagine!
** Tastings are available for wedding cakes. Inquire with us to learn more!
Sizes & Servings
single tier
4" Smash Cake (2-4) | $15
6" Round (8-10) | $45
8" Round (12-16) | $60
10" Round (20-30) | $75
12" Round (40-50) | $95
Additional charges for custom decor.
sheet cakes
Used for pre-scored cakes only.
1/4 Sheet (15) | $40
1/2 Sheet (40) | $70
tiered cakes
Inquire for custom pricing.
Two Tier:
4" & 6" (10-12)
6" & 8" (20-25)
8" & 10" (40-45)
10" & 12" (70-75)
Three Tier:
4" & 6" & 8" (35)
6" & 8" & 10" (55)
8" & 10" & 12" (90)
INQUIRE NOW
view gallery
Flavors & Fillings
batter flavors +
Number/letter cakes
1/4 Sheet each $90
1/2 Sheet each $120
Prices include custom decor.
heart cakes
6" Heart (6-8) $65
8" Heart (10-12) $80
*(Numbers in parentheses are serving sizes)
delivery available for $2.00/mile
Vanilla
Chocolate
Double Chocolate Chip
Almond
Red Velvet
Funfetti
Cookie Dough
Strawberry
Lemon
Orange
Carrot
Apple Cinnamon
Pumpkin
Cookies & Cream
Custom Cupcakes
Whether ordered on their own or paired with other treats, cupcakes make for the perfect party staple.
Choose from the cake flavors & fillings above, or explore our gourmet options!
Sizes & Servings
cupcakes
Minimum of a dozen mini cupcakes per flavor OR 6 regular per flavor.
Minis | $18 per dozen
Regular (no filling) | $2.50
Decorated (design & filling) | $3.00
Gourmet Cupcakes | $3.75
Gourmet cupcakes
Apple Cinnamon Crumble
Almond Torte
Birthday Cake
Cannoli Chocolate Chip
Cinnamon Roll
Chocolate Strawberry
Cookie Dough
Death by Chocolate
Fudge Brownie
Lemon Blueberry
inquire now
view gallery
Nutella Hazelnut
Orange Creamsicle
Oreo Overload
Peanut Butter Cup
Salted Caramel Pretzel
Strawberry Shortcake
Strawberry Pretzel
S'Mores
Snickers
Vanilla Raspberry Swirl
delivery available for $2.00/mile
apple cinnamon crumble
Apple cinnamon cake with apple filling with our vanilla buttercream, rimmed with oatmeal crumble.
almond torte
Almond cake with vanilla bavarian cream filling, vanilla buttercream topped with sugared/toasted almonds.
birthday cake
Vanilla funfetti cake with sprinkle filling, sprinkles and vanilla buttercream, topped with a candle lollipop and cake flavored treats.
Cannoli chocolate chip
Vanilla chocolate chip cake with cannoli cream filling, vanilla buttercream topped with chocolate chips and a mini cannoli.
chocolate strawberry
Chocolate cake with chocolate strawberry mouse filling, strawberry buttercream, topped with a fresh strawberry and chocolate ganache.
Cookie Dough
Cookie dough cake, vanilla buttercream, topped with chocolate chips, crushed cookie and chocolate chip cookie.
death by chocolate
Double chocolate cake with fudge filling, chocolate buttercream topped with chocolate treats.
fudge brownie
Chocolate cake, chocolate buttercream, chocolate fudge with homemade chocolate fudge brownies on top.
lemon blueberry
Lemon cake with fresh lemon filling, blueberry buttercream topped with fresh blueberries and candy lemon slice.
nutella hazelnut
Chocolate cake with Nutella filling, hazelnut buttercream, topped with ferro Roche and nutella drizzle.
Orange creamsicle
Fresh orange cake, vanilla mouse filling, orange and vanilla buttercream, topped with an orange candy slice.
oreo overload
Cookies and cream cake, oreo buttercream and vanilla buttercream, topped with oreo crumbles an oreo and chocolate ganache drizzle.
peanut butter cup
Chocolate cake with peanut butter filling, peanut butter buttercream, topped with crushed Reeses pieces and a large Reeses cup on top.
salted caramel pretzel
Vanilla cupcake with caramel filling, salted caramel buttercream, topped with chewy caramel, sea salt, and a pretzel.
strawberry shortcake
Strawberry cake with strawberry jam filling, vanilla buttercream, topped with strawberry crunch and a fresh strawberry on top.
strawberry pretzels
Vanilla cake, pretzel crust bottom, with strawberry jam filling, strawberry buttercream, rimmed with pretzels and fresh strawberry on top.
s'mores
Chocolate or vanilla cake, chocolate buttercream and toasted meringue, topped with chocolate, toasted mini marshmallows and graham cracker.
snickers
Vanilla cinnamon cake, cinnamon buttercream, topped with vanilla drizzle and mini cinnamon sugar doughnut.
vanilla raspberry swirl
Vanilla cake with raspberry jam filling, raspberry and vanilla buttercream swirl, topped with fresh raspberry and white chocolate curls.
cinnamon roll
Vanilla cinnamon cake with vanilla buttercream cream, mini cinnamon roll and drizzle of cinnamon roll icing.
Chocolate Dipped
Life is always better with a little chocolate—whether you're going for something simple & classic like strawberries, or something more decadent like Oreos, chocolate dipped treats make for a great addition to any tablescape.
Sizes & Servings
chocolate dipped
Pretzel Rods | $2.00
Cake Pops | $2.00
- Vanilla, Chocolate, Funfetti, Red Velvet
- Vanilla, Chocolate, Funfetti, Red Velvet
bagging
inquire now
view gallery
Individual Bagging | 0.50¢ / item
Bagging with Bow | $1.00/item
delivery available for $2.00/mile
Other Treats
While we focus on cakes, cupcakes, & cookies, we also know how beloved brownies and dessert cups are.
Have another idea? Reach out—we'd love to see if we can make it happen for you!
Brownies & Dessert Cups
brownies
Mini | $1.50 (in regular fudge only)
Regular | $2.25
Specialty Flavor | $3.50
- S'mores, Caramel Pretzel, Peanut Butter, Chocolate Explosion, Andes Candies, Cookies and Cream
inquire now
view gallery
Dozen | $40.00
- Birthday Cake
- Caramel Apple
- Cookie Dough
- Cookies & Cream
- Chocolate Explosion
- Lemon Meringue
- Strawberry Lemonade
- Strawberry Shortcake
- Peanut Butter Cup
- Toasted Almond
- S'Mores
- Canolli
delivery available for $2.00/mile
individual dessert cups
So... how does it work?
you order
we discuss
i bake
you party!
Fill out the order form on the contact page with your information and event details, & we'll get the ball rolling!
Bringing your vision to life is our greatest priority. Depending on your order, we'll chat via email or phone about your dream treat.
Once the details are ironed out, I go shopping, come up with a gameplan, and start baking whatever we discussed!
You can either pick up your order before your event or we can deliver; then, it's time to party, relax, & enjoy!
whaddya say?
Ready to put in your order? We're so excited to for you!
At Icing on the Cake, we believe the details matter—and custom treats can take any event from fun to fabulous. We'd love to create something special for you & your guests.
Ready to make this official? Fill out our order form with as much detail as possible to request your custom treats. We'll be in touch within 48 business hours about next steps!
inquire now
bake
home
about
menu
gallery
faq's
inquire
